I commented on RetailWire in early January about Macy’s announcement of 2017 store closures:
I saw with a particular shudder that one of the Macy’s stores on the list is the “flagship” location in downtown Minneapolis — the old Dayton’s headquarters, where my wife and I both worked and eventually met. It’s hard to imagine that a store with an appropriately sized footprint can’t thrive in downtown Minneapolis — full of office workers and residents — unless there is something fundamentally wrong with how Macy’s is running its business. I’ve shopped their stores from California to Florida to Nevada to Illinois over the past couple of years, and continue to be disappointed by the merchandise content, the physical condition of the stores and the service experience. Until Macy’s addresses these “Retail 101” issues, it doesn’t matter how many stores they close.
Additional thoughts from RetailWire:
Some of our observations about Macy’s are based on 20/20 hindsight, not based on what seemed like a smart move at the time. Even though there was plenty of debate about the disappearance of powerful local nameplates like Marshall Field’s, the reality is that several of those retailers were in their own slow decline. So Macy’s effort to create a national brand (and economies of scale) paid off for awhile.
Where Macy’s has lost its way is in the failure of the “My Macy’s” initiative to cater more effectively to local tastes. The best data science in the world may not be a substitute for experienced managers who really understand their customers’ taste (and when things sell in a given climate). But the bigger issue is the overassortment of women’s brands, erosion of customer service and lack of capital spending; no amount of localization can overcome those hurdles.
And to add a final thought after visiting Macy’s Manhattan flagship in early March: This is a spectacular store that has gotten a big boost in capital investment over the last few years. But Macy’s is so focused on this location (visible to its investors, suppliers and competitors) that it has neglected hundreds of other locations around the country.